Can KISS OF LIFE Be Forgiven: Fans Debate Fallout Over Racist Livestream Scandal
K-pop girl group KISS OF LIFE is facing intense scrutiny following a controversial livestream that many fans have called out for its “racist” content, sparking wide-ranging discussions about accountability, cultural sensitivity, and redemption.
During member Julie’s birthday livestream, the group’s “old-school hip hop” theme sparked backlash for reinforcing Black cultural stereotypes. The controversy led to their KCON performance being canceled, impacting their image and career.
On Reddit, international fans have engaged in heated debate over the group’s future, with one user sparking conversation by asking, “what would it take for people to forgive kiss of life?” They also questioned whether the group’s apology letter was sufficient.
For many, the answer is no. Some fans point to Julie’s previous controversies, including her past use of the n-word, as evidence of a pattern rather than a one-off mistake.
Another common sentiment is the need for a more genuine and public apology. As one user put it, “A written statement might put out the fire, but only real education and appreciation can rebuild trust.” Suggestions for a path forward include a verbal acknowledgment, clear efforts to engage with anti-racist education, and direct outreach to affected communities.
However, forgiveness isn’t seen as a guaranteed outcome. “Redemption has no timeline,” one fan noted. Others added that Black fans, in particular, should not be pressured to forgive, with one commenter saying, “Let them grieve without being pestered.”
Fueling further outrage, Julie’s name resurfaced recently due to her upcoming collaboration with Red Velvet’s IRENE & SEULGI, reigniting the controversy among fans who feel the group hasn’t properly addressed the damage done.
As KISS OF LIFE attempts to move forward, their response, or lack thereof, may determine whether they can recover their rising-star momentum or remain stalled by unresolved controversy.
